Phone: (262) 785-0840

Southeastern Wisconsin Apartments for Rent

Are You Responding to Positive Online Reviews the Wrong Way?

Most businesses understand the importance of online reviews. Positive Google reviews attract customers, while negative reviews can send them straight to the competition.

But what happens after someone leaves a glowing five-star review?

Surprisingly, many businesses may be responding in exactly the wrong way.

Research discussed in The Wall Street Journal by Katherine C. Lafreniere and Yi Wei suggests that businesses can actually hurt themselves by responding to compliments in ways that sound self-congratulatory.

Consider an apartment resident who writes:

“The maintenance team was fantastic! They fixed my furnace immediately!”

A typical management response might be:

“Thank you for your five-star review! We’re so glad you had a great experience with our maintenance team. Providing exceptional service to our residents is always our top priority!”

Sounds familiar, doesn’t it?

There’s nothing particularly offensive about that response. In fact, it’s the sort of thing businesses have been encouraged to write for years.

But notice what happened. A resident complimented the maintenance team, and management responded by talking about its own commitment to exceptional service.

The compliment became an advertisement.

Gratitude Is Good. Self-Congratulation Isn’t.

The researchers found that repeating positive aspects of customer reviews could actually reduce subsequent customer ratings compared with not responding at all.

Across 12 experiments involving more than 7,000 participants, responses demonstrating humility consistently performed better than responses expressing gratitude alone.

The lesson isn’t to stop thanking customers. It’s to stop using every compliment as an opportunity to tell customers how wonderful your business is.

Consider a different response:

“Thanks for taking the time to leave a review! I’ll make sure our maintenance team sees your comments. They’ll appreciate hearing that their work made a difference.”

That sounds like one person responding to another.

It thanks the resident, acknowledges the experience, and gives credit to the employees who actually earned the praise.

No marketing slogans. No corporate self-congratulation.

Give Credit Where It’s Due

That’s particularly important in property management.

A successful apartment community depends on maintenance technicians, leasing agents, cleaners, groundskeepers, and other employees whose work residents experience every day.

When a resident compliments those employees, management should recognize them rather than turn the compliment into an advertisement for the company.

And don’t just promise to pass along the praise. Actually do it.

Employees deserve to know when their efforts are appreciated.

Don’t Turn Reviews Into a Popularity Contest

There’s another problem I’ve observed during nearly 40 years in the apartment business.

Some property managers become remarkably good at generating positive reviews about themselves.

Not about the apartments. Not about maintenance or the experience of living at the property.

About the manager personally.

Sometimes these reviews come from residents who have barely moved in.

That raises an uncomfortable question: Are we measuring resident satisfaction, or an employee’s ability to solicit compliments?

There’s nothing wrong with residents praising an outstanding manager. But online reviews should help prospective customers evaluate a business, not become a personal popularity contest.

A five-star review about a friendly leasing experience doesn’t necessarily tell someone what it’s like to live in that apartment six months later.

What About Negative Reviews?

Negative reviews require a different approach, but the same principle applies: Respond like a person, not a public relations department.

Don’t argue with the resident. Don’t become defensive. And don’t disclose private information in an attempt to prove management was right.

Acknowledge the concern, offer to investigate, and provide a reasonable way to continue the conversation privately.

If the business made a mistake, take responsibility.

Remember, your response isn’t just for the person who complained. It’s also for every prospective customer who reads the exchange.

A thoughtful response to a negative review can sometimes tell customers more about your business than a dozen glowing five-star ratings.

The Bottom Line

Online reviews aren’t just about what customers say about your business.

They’re also about how your business responds.

Thank customers for sharing their experiences. Recognize employees who deserve credit. Address legitimate complaints professionally.

And resist the temptation to turn every compliment into an advertisement for how wonderful you are.

The best response to a five-star review isn’t to give yourself five stars. It’s to demonstrate why the customer gave them to you in the first place.

Facebook
X
LinkedIn
Email

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *